Twitter   RSS   Email  

 How the Global Economy is Dependent on Christianity

 Why America May Never Recover From the Recession

 Save Money Homeschooling

Obama’s Healthcare Reform Will Be a Colossal Failure, Causing Prices to Increase Even Faster: Part 2

By: Steve Johnson

7/21/2009 - 13 Comments

Obama’s healthcare reform bill will expand the government’s role in healthcare and create an even larger system of price controls, increasing the cost for everyone.

This is part 2 in an article series addressing the current healthcare reform proposal by President Obama.

Yesterday, I explained why the payment system is so distorted and today I’m addressing why sharing more information about prices will not solve anything.

The second part of Obama's solution to reduce healthcare costs is:

2. Knowledge is not shared as much as it could be

Obama suggests that if knowledge of clinical effectiveness and cost could be obtained and shared, then costs could be reduced. 

The problem is that prices can never be evaluated with effectiveness because many prices are fixed by local government regulations and therefore do not accurately reflect effectiveness. Most of the prices for medical services are based on the government's system of pricing - Medicare.  The problem is again the middle man. 

The only tool capable of evaluating costs with effectiveness is the free market, which does not exist because the government fixes prices.

Therefore, Obama’s plan to collect this information and analysis it will not result in any increase in effectiveness or reduction in cost, and instead will increase the cost of healthcare to pay for the system of collecting and sharing the information.

Gabriel E. Vidal recently wrote an excellent article addressing healthcare reform, here is a quote further explaining this position:

“Contrary to Obama's suggestion that knowledge of clinical effectiveness and cost effectiveness can be obtained and disseminated, there is no rational way to evaluate cost effectiveness outside of the free market. Central health planners cannot compare and recommend the best option between two different combinations of drugs, hospitals, and physicians to treat a particular ailment.

It is not just a matter of figuring out which combination offers better outcomes and lower costs. In fact, the bureaucrat actually needs prices to make that comparison! This is also why Obama's ideas on payment reform to change how Medicare pays providers, and knowledge reform to investigate which treatments are most cost effective will never work and will increase costs and reduce quality.”

There is no value in sharing knowledge about prices that are based on a system of fixed prices. This would only close the loop for a complete government run healthcare system and give the government complete control of what service you get. The government would be both setting the prices and collecting price information related to effectiveness. 

Therefore, they would be in complete control of giving you the service they want based on the reports they generate.  They could give you bad medical service and tell you that according to the effectiveness and cost sharing information, you are getting the best service.  So when you have to wait three years for a medical procedure, you could take comfort knowing that you are getting the very best service possible.

I would prefer the system we have now with all its problems. I don't want to reduce my quality of care or pay more for it.

Tomorrow, I will address third part of the proposed healthcare reform in part 3 of this article series.

Obama’s Healthcare Reform Will Be a Colossal Failure, Causing Prices to Increase Even Faster: Part 1

Obama’s Healthcare Reform Will Be a Colossal Failure, Causing Prices to Increase Even Faster: Part 2

Obama’s Healthcare Reform Will Be a Colossal Failure, Causing Prices to Increase Even Faster: Part 3

Obama’s Healthcare Reform Will Be a Colossal Failure, Causing Prices to Increase Even Faster: Part 4 

Copyright © 2019 All rights reserved.

Meltdown: A Free-Market Look at Why the Stock Market Collapsed, the Economy Tanked, and Government Bailouts Will Make Things Worse

In discussions of today's economic meltdown and what to do about it, the Federal Reserve is a stealth helicopter: it never shows up on the radar. With the exception of a few esoteric specialists and those Ron Paul Revolutionaries who burst into chants of "Abolish the Fed!" Historian Thomas Woods notes in this important book, the Federal Reserve bears a large part of the blame for the mess we're in. In the first part of "Meltdown," Woods shows how both in theory and in practice, Fed policy fueled an artificial boom and is now leading us to a much larger meltdown.

The Case Against the Fed

This book, written by Murray Rothbard, an economist and historian of fairly well known repute, is a scathing attack on not only the Federal Reserve, but the interests that created this institution. Rothbard explains how the Federal Reserve is the true source in the destruction of wealth, which has led to the destruction of the middle class and continues to sift money into the hands of the wealthiest.

Crash Proof

Peter Schiff has predicted the economic hardship more accurately then any other economist in the world in this book. Everything from the housing crash to the credit crunch to the stock market. Peter has a plan to help you servive the crash. Peter explains why the Wall Street investment firms are still trying to sell you stocks, and was the house prices are likely to continue to decline for years to come.

Gold: The Once and Future Money

Governments and central bankers around the world today unanimously agree on the desirability of stable money, ever more so after some monetary disaster has reduced yet another economy to smoking ruins. Lewis shows how gold provides the stability needed to foster greater prosperity and productivity throughout the world. He offers an insightful look at money in all its forms, from the seventh century B.C. to the present day, explaining in straightforward layman’s terms the effects of inflation, deflation, and floating currencies along with their effect on prices, wages, taxes, and debt.