Twitter   RSS   Email  

Curtis Ophoven's eBooks

 Why America May Never Recover From the Recession


 Save Money Homeschooling


When the Numbers Don’t Work Out, Change the Accounting Rules

By: Curtis Ophoven

2/6/2009 - 5 Comments

That doesn’t sound like good monetary policy to me, but that is exactly what the government in proposing.

Senator Christopher Dodd, the Democratic chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, told reporters on Wednesday that he would consider changing the mark-to-market accounting regulation rules. 

You see the problem is that the banks don’t want to mark their assets at their true value, because for much of their sub-prime and derivative assets the true value is zero.  In the current market condition, the value of trillions of dollars of bank assets is zero because there is no one interesting in buying these assets at any price.

If the banks mark down their assets to their market value (mark-to-market), many of them would be insolvent.  To solve this problem, the same senators who creating the housing bubble by creating the rules that allowed Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae to expand, are now suggesting that we just change the accounting rules.

Their theory is that the banks shouldn’t have to mark down their assets to near zero because some day in the future - the assets will against be worth something.  Enron tried a similar trick when it adjusted its accounting rules to move high risk assets off its books and we all know what happen.

If the banks have trillions of dollars in near-zero assets, than the billions in bailouts are not going to be nearly enough the save them.  Many banks will eventually fail unless the market returns to pre-crash prosperity.

The problem is not the accounting rules, it’s the assets.  The assets are worthless and probably will continue to be worthless even after the recession runs its course.  The hard truth is that many of the US banks are insolvent and the economy will eventually have to deal with that.

Meanwhile, the recession continues to deepen, as US employers slashed 598,000 jobs in January, the deepest cut in payrolls in 34 years as the national unemployment rate shot up to 7.6 percent.

Copyright © 2010 PennyJobs.com. All rights reserved.

<< FREE >> Weekly Newsletter...

Signup today and start receiving our free weekly newsletter!

Reader Comments

Comment 1
Hank Says: on Friday, February 06, 2009 9:47:23 AM

We created the "Mark to Market" Rule out of thin air after the Enron debacle. Why should companies have to write down assets before they sell them? Which is what this rule mandates. The government helped create these companies' liquidity problems through the unintended consequences of this rule. Asset prices should not be adjusted on companies' books for accounting purposes until they are sold.

www.OwnTheDollar.com


Comment 2
DAN O Says: on Friday, February 06, 2009 3:59:01 PM

I agree with Hank on this one. Our Government tends to overreact when faced with a current problem not putting much thought into how it will effect other aspects of the market. That overraction after enron has been a major problem for banks now. The government is just about to make another overreaction with this stimulus package. Fear is a great salesman. I forget His last name.

Comment 3
Curt Says: on Friday, February 06, 2009 4:12:29 PM

@Hank and Dan - Interesting point of view. But, if the assets are worthless, changing this accounting rule is not going to change that - only delay the time in which that assets will be truely marked-to-market when they are sold at some point in the future.

And if the banks are allows to claim their assets are worth more then the market, then aren't they just lying to their share holders?

If we change this accounting rule, then who knows what any bank is actually worth and their is no way to stop a bank or a company from lying about their asset values.


Comment 4
maggie Says: on Monday, February 09, 2009 9:41:25 AM

We should stick with the truth and accept the consequences---seems to be lying only makes Pinnochiole nose grow longer--and have more problems--

Write a Comment

Please keep comments civil and on-topic. Abusive or inappropriate comments will be removed without warning.

 Name (required)   
 Email Address (required)   
 Website URL 
Comment  
 

Related Articles

  • The Fiat Money System Is Failing
  • Since the dollar was removed from the gold standard in 1971, the world financial system has been based on confidence, while governments have done all they can to compete in who can destroy their currency faster. Read More...
  • Capitalism Will Have Its Way With The Economy
  • The government economic central planning will get overrun by the forces of capitalism. Read More...
  • US Debt is a Sub-Prime Mortgage
  • The budget deficit for the 2008 budget year will jump to $250 billion, the Congressional Budget Office estimated Wednesday, citing the weakening economy. Read More...
  • Why We Should Not Give More Control of the Economy to the Government
  • In short – no matter what they do, they will not be able to stop the recession and most of their efforts will make it worse.  Read More...
  • So Much for the Governments Role Being Temporary
  • In a speech Friday, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke said that the federal government will need to continue to play a role in the future of the mortgage financing market. Read More...
The Speculation Economy

American businesses today are obsessed with the price of their stock, and no wonder. The consequences of even a modest decrease can be so dire that some executives would rather damage their corporation's long-term health than allow quarterly returns to fall below projections. But how did this situation come about? When did the stock market become the driver of the American economy? Lawrence E. Mitchell identifies the moment in American history when finance triumphed over industry.

Crash Proof

Peter Schiff has predicted the economic hardship more accurately then any other economist in the world in this book. Everything from the housing crash to the credit crunch to the stock market. Peter has a plan to help you servive the crash. Peter explains why the Wall Street investment firms are still trying to sell you stocks, and was the house prices are likely to continue to decline for years to come.

Day of Reckoning

In Day of Reckoning, Pat Buchanan reveals the true existential crisis of the nation and shows how President Bush's post-9/11 conversion to an ideology of 'democratism' led us to the precipice of strategic disaster abroad and savage division at home. Ideology, writes Buchanan, is a false god that seeks vainly to create a paradise on earth. While free enterprise is good, the worship of a 'free trade' that is destroying the dollar, de-industrializing America, and ending our economic independence, is cult madness.

Debt is Slavery

Michael gets to the point in just over a hundred pages. Most people do not have a good relationship with money. They have never taken the time to figure out how to use money to provide no only the essentials of life, but freedom and opportunity. Michael explains how to have 50% of your salary and gives a step by step example of how to create a budget and eliminate debt.